Skip to main content Skip to navigation within this section
Abuse in Care - Royal Commission of Inquiry

Abuse in Care - Royal Commission of Inquiry

This Royal Commission is an independent inquiry into abuse in state care and in the care of faith-based institutions in Aotearoa New Zealand.

  • Reports Ngā pūrongo
    • Whanaketia
    • Stolen Lives, Marked Souls
    • Beautiful Children: Inquiry into the Lake Alice Child and Adolescent Unit
    • He Purapura Ora, he Māra Tipu from Redress to Puretumu Torowhānui
    • Tāwharautia: Interim Report
    • Administrative Report
  • Survivors Ngā purapura ora
    • Survivor experiences
    • Survivor videos
    • Getting help and support
  • Research and engagement Rangahau me ngā tūhonhono
    • How people engaged with the Inquiry
    • Public hearings
    • Research
    • Evidence library
  • Background material Ngā raupapa tuara
    • About the Royal Commission
    • Inquiry team
    • Advisory groups and reference groups
    • Quarterly reports
    • Timeline
    • Questions and answers
    • Pānui
    • News
  • Document library Kohinga tuhinga
    • Document library
    • Case studies
    • Recommendations
    • Summaries and guides
Quick Exit
178a v2
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Beautiful Children: Inquiry into the Lake Alice Child and Adolescent Unit
  • 2.2.8 Interaction with the criminal justice system
Listen

2.2.8 Interaction with the criminal justice system Te whai wāhitanga ki te pūnaha kōti

526.    Many survivors of State care, including some Lake Alice survivors, ended up in the youth and criminal justice systems – what is sometimes referred to as the ‘care-to-custody pipeline’.[1146] The causes are often related to substance abuse, lack of supports and financial security, and unresolved anger and aggression.[1147] We heard of several survivors who, soon after their release, committed crimes, usually theft, to survive. One survivor said he struggled to live with the memories of what happened in Lake Alice, started to misbehave at school, which he saw as the start of turning to gangs for security.[1148] He said, “I turned to gangs and crime. This was the easiest way to make money because I couldn’t hold down a nine-to-five job due to the emotional trauma I was constantly battling”.[1149]

527.    As we noted in our care to custody research report, there are clear links – for Māori and non-Māori – between experiences in State care and later imprisonment.[1150] The research found that one in five and, sometimes, as many as one in three children and young people who had been in State residential care went on to serve a criminal custodial sentence later in life. The proportion of Māori who had been in State residential care and subsequently received a custodial sentence was much higher than for non-Māori.[1151] This is a much higher rate than that of people who had not been in State care.[1152]

528.    Some survivors went on to spend a large portion of their lives in prison – some for serious offending and others for a succession of minor offences. Some recognised they had become institutionalised and felt more comfortable inside prison than outside. As Mr Rangi Wickliffe told us:

“I was diagnosed with terminal cancer while I was in prison, and that was one of the reasons they let me out in October 2017. That was actually hard for me because that was the only life I have known. It was my home. The Department of Corrections just cut the cord. That felt like more of the abandonment that I had previously suffered from my mother and my family … I wanted to go back to jail; that’s how hard it was for me … I cannot cope in everyday society because of the extreme pain, fear, and suffering I endured at Lake Alice … I cannot handle it on the outside. It is why I think I have spent so long in prison – because I can handle it on the inside, because it is where I can hide from what has happened to me. In jail, I am fine; on the outside, I do not cope.”[1153]

  Many survivors of State care, including some Lake Alice survivors, ended up in the youth and criminal justice systems - what is sometimes referred to as the 'care-to-custody pipeline'.  The causes are often related to substance abuse, lack of supports and financial security, and unresolved anger and aggression.  

Next page -->

2.2 Impact of the abuse
  • 2.2 Impact of the abuse
  • 2.2.2 Impacts of abuse on every aspect of survivors’ lives
  • 2.2.3 Effects on spiritual wellbeing
  • 2.2.4 Effects on cognitive and mental health
  • 2.2.5 Physical health
  • 2.2.6 Effects on whānau health
  • 2.2.7 Effects on education and employment
  • 2.2.8 Interaction with the criminal justice system
  • 2.2.9 Stigma of Lake Alice and impact on mana
  • Rangi Wickliffe
Site Logo Light
Connect with us
  • Find us on Facebook


    • Legal Menu
      • Privacy policy
      • Terms
      • Accessibility
      • Contact us
    • Ngā pūrongo Reports
      • Whanaketia
      • Stolen Lives, Marked Souls
      • Beautiful Children
      • He Purapura Ora, he Māra Tipu
      • Tāwharautia: Pūrongo o te Wā
      • Administrative report
    • Ngā purapura ora Survivors
      • Getting help and support
      • Questions and answers
      • Survivor stories
    • Rangahau me ngā tūhonhono Research and engagement
      • How people engaged with the Inquiry
      • Public hearings
      • Research
    • Te tuara me tōna raupapa Background and material
      • About the Royal Commission
      • Inquiry team
      • Advisory Groups and Reference Groups
      • Quarterly reports
      • Timeline
      • Pānui
    • Kohinga tuhinga Document library
      • Document Library
      • Case studies
      • Recommendations
      • Summaries and guides

    © 2025 Abuse in Care - Royal Commission of Inquiry