Skip to main content Skip to navigation within this section
Abuse in Care - Royal Commission of Inquiry

Abuse in Care - Royal Commission of Inquiry

This Royal Commission is an independent inquiry into abuse in state care and in the care of faith-based institutions in Aotearoa New Zealand.

  • Reports Ngā pūrongo
    • Whanaketia
    • Stolen Lives, Marked Souls
    • Beautiful Children: Inquiry into the Lake Alice Child and Adolescent Unit
    • He Purapura Ora, he Māra Tipu from Redress to Puretumu Torowhānui
    • Tāwharautia: Interim Report
    • Administrative Report
  • Survivors Ngā purapura ora
    • Survivor experiences
    • Survivor videos
    • Getting help and support
  • Research and engagement Rangahau me ngā tūhonhono
    • How people engaged with the Inquiry
    • Public hearings
    • Research
    • Evidence library
  • Background material Ngā raupapa tuara
    • About the Royal Commission
    • Inquiry team
    • Advisory groups and reference groups
    • Quarterly reports
    • Timeline
    • Questions and answers
    • Pānui
    • News
  • Document library Kohinga tuhinga
    • Document library
    • Case studies
    • Recommendations
    • Summaries and guides
Quick Exit
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Whanaketia
  • Case studies
  • Out of sight, out of mind: Kimberley Centre
  • Chapter 7: Redress for survivors who were at the Kimberley Centre
Listen

Chapter 7: Redress for survivors who were at the Kimberley Centre

237. As set out in more detail in the Inquiry’s redress report, He Purapura Ora, he Māra Tipu: From Redress to Puretumu Torowhānui, survivors could make a redress claim through the responsible State agencies’ out-of-court claims process. The redress available varied between agencies but could include an apology, a financial payment, a contribution towards legal aid debt and counselling. However, as set out in that report, many survivors who did use such processes found them to be slow, difficult to navigate and inconsistent in terms of what they offered.[277]

238. The Inquiry has heard that most Kimberley Centre survivors have not received adequate redress for the abuse and neglect they suffered. Of the survivors that the Inquiry has heard from, most have not sought redress, and some have difficulty even contemplating their right to redress.[278] Many will not have known that they could seek redress from the State.

239. European survivor Sir Robert Martin did not make a civil claim. He passed away earlier this year without receiving any form of redress. He knew of other abuse survivors who had made claims, including some who took a class action in relation to Lake Alice. “Some years ago I was told about some lawyers I could go to but I didn’t as I thought this would be too hard. I think it is difficult for people with disabilities to know how to make a claim.”[279] Sir Robert stated that if he was going to make a claim he would have claimed for the medication and sexual abuse he suffered, which should never have happened.[280] New Zealand European survivor Ross Hamilton Clark has not made a report to NZ Police, a claim to ACC, or sought compensation from the government for the abuse he suffered at the Kimberley Centre.[281]

240. New Zealand European survivor Mr EI spent time in care in a number of State institutions (Hokio Beach School, the Kimberley Centre, and Epuni Boys’ Home) and sought redress from the Ministry of Social Development and ACC. After four years, he received a financial payout and letter of apology from the Ministry of Social Development.[282] ACC initially declined his sensitive claim and he had to appeal and fight for it to be accepted. The claim was ultimately accepted but he received only $3,000, plus a quarterly payment of $300. He viewed the amount he received as pittance for 50 years of suffering.[283] More recently, in 2022, he filed further claims with the Ministry of Health and Ministry of Education. He was advised that it would take around three years before each claim is considered, however his claim against the Ministry of Health was settled in November 2022.

 

Footnotes

[277] Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care, He Purapura Ora, he Māra Tipu: From Redress to Puretumu Torowhānui, Volume 1 (2021, page 144).

[278] Mirfin-Veitch, B, Tikao, K, Asaka, U, Tuisaula, E, Stace, H, Watene, FR & Frawley, P, Tell me about you: A life story approach to understanding disabled people’s experiences in care (1950–1999), (Donald Beasley Institute, 2022, page 16).

[279] Witness statement of Sir Robert Martin (17 October 2019, para 68).

[280] Witness statement of Sir Robert Martin (17 October 2019, pages 22–23).

[281] Witness statement of Ross Hamilton Clark (15 February 2022, page 3, para 3.1).

[282] Transcript of evidence of Mr EI at the Inquiry’s Ūhia te Māramatanga Disability, Deaf and Mental Health Institutional Care Hearing (Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in Care, 11 July 2022, page 61).

[283] Witness statement of Mr EI (20 February 2021, paras 4.5–4.8).

Out of sight, out of mind: Kimberley Centre
  • He karakia
  • Out of sight, out of mind: Kimberley Centre
  • Chapter 1: Introduction
  • Chapter 2: Context
  • Survivor experience: Irene Priest
  • Chapter 3: Circumstances that led to disabled children, young people and adults being placed at the Kimberley Centre
  • Chapter 4: Nature and extent of abuse and neglect at the Kimberley Centre
  • Survivor experience: Sir Robert Martin
  • Chapter 5: Impacts of abuse and neglect at the Kimberley Centre
  • Chapter 6: Factors that caused or contributed to abuse and neglect at the Kimberley Centre
  • Survivor experience: Lusi Faiva
  • Chapter 7: Redress for survivors who were at the Kimberley Centre
  • Chapter 8: The closure of the Kimberley Centre
  • Chapter 9: Key findings on the Kimberley Centre
  • He waiata
Site Logo Light
Connect with us
  • Find us on Facebook


    • Legal Menu
      • Privacy policy
      • Terms
      • Accessibility
      • Contact us
    • Ngā pūrongo Reports
      • Whanaketia
      • Stolen Lives, Marked Souls
      • Beautiful Children
      • He Purapura Ora, he Māra Tipu
      • Tāwharautia: Pūrongo o te Wā
      • Administrative report
    • Ngā purapura ora Survivors
      • Getting help and support
      • Questions and answers
      • Survivor stories
    • Rangahau me ngā tūhonhono Research and engagement
      • How people engaged with the Inquiry
      • Public hearings
      • Research
    • Te tuara me tōna raupapa Background and material
      • About the Royal Commission
      • Inquiry team
      • Advisory Groups and Reference Groups
      • Quarterly reports
      • Timeline
      • Pānui
    • Kohinga tuhinga Document library
      • Document Library
      • Case studies
      • Recommendations
      • Summaries and guides

    © 2025 Abuse in Care - Royal Commission of Inquiry