Skip to main content Skip to navigation within this section
Abuse in Care - Royal Commission of Inquiry

Abuse in Care - Royal Commission of Inquiry

This Royal Commission is an independent inquiry into abuse in state care and in the care of faith-based institutions in Aotearoa New Zealand.

  • Reports Ngā pūrongo
    • Whanaketia
    • Stolen Lives, Marked Souls
    • Beautiful Children: Inquiry into the Lake Alice Child and Adolescent Unit
    • He Purapura Ora, he Māra Tipu from Redress to Puretumu Torowhānui
    • Tāwharautia: Interim Report
    • Administrative Report
  • Survivors Ngā purapura ora
    • Survivor experiences
    • Survivor videos
    • Getting help and support
  • Research and engagement Rangahau me ngā tūhonhono
    • How people engaged with the Inquiry
    • Public hearings
    • Research
    • Evidence library
  • Background material Ngā raupapa tuara
    • About the Royal Commission
    • Inquiry team
    • Advisory groups and reference groups
    • Quarterly reports
    • Timeline
    • Questions and answers
    • Pānui
    • News
  • Document library Kohinga tuhinga
    • Document library
    • Case studies
    • Recommendations
    • Summaries and guides
Quick Exit
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Whanaketia
  • Survivor experiences
  • Survivor experience: Keith Wiffin
Listen

Survivor experience: Keith Wiffin Ngā wheako o te purapura ora

Age when entered care: 11 years old
Year of birth: 1959
Type of care facility: Boys’ homes – Epuni Boys’ Home, Family Home
Ethnicity: Pākehā
Whānau background: Keith lived with his mum and dad, two sisters and a younger brother. Keith’s dad passed away suddenly when Keith was only 10 years old.

Keith Wiffin, wearing a dark jacket with a light coloured jumper, smiling and looking directly at the camera

I went into State care after my father died on his 39th birthday, leaving a mother trying to care for four children with very little income or support. I was 10 years old at the time. I had two sisters and a younger brother. My mother was not able to care for us after my father’s death. That, plus my reaction to my dad’s death, led to the decision to place me into care.

There was a brief court appearance, and I was placed in State care. Next thing, I was in a van being driven to Epuni Boys’ Home, Lower Hutt. For the next nine months I had very sporadic contact with my family. It was hard to have any contact, even to write letters, and contact was not encouraged.

My introduction to the culture at Epuni started in the van on the way out there. There were a lot of other children in the van. One boy in particular didn’t like the look of me, and smashed a guitar over my head. I walked into the place picking bits of wood out of my head - that was my welcome.

The culture was violent and abusive. The boys had what they called a “kingpin” system. Fights and bullying were routine. I personally had broken bones and required medical treatment, including stitches.

It was a devastating experience to go into that, coming from a loving home and trying to deal with losing my father. The culture of violence was totally foreign to me. There had been nothing like that going on at home – we faced hardship, but there was never any abuse.

In many cases, the staff either perpetrated or oversaw the violence. The house masters were all very violent themselves. They wouldn’t hesitate to use physical violence. I saw a fair bit of that. Psychologically they made it quite clear we were second-class citizens and the most likely outcome in life was that we would go to prison. There weren’t many positive messages. It was an abusive and negative environment. Once you were in it, there were huge obstacles to success. We became products of an environment overseen by the staff.

The staff encouraged the kingpin system and used it as a means of control. The kingpin himself would be respected by the staff and used. If they thought somebody needed sorting out, they would turn to the kingpin to get that done.

I remember a camp in the Akatorua Valley. There were three cabins and there were fights going on in each cabin to determine who would be the kingpin. I was involved in a couple of those fights and my hand was broken. The whole process was overseen and encouraged by the staff who were there.

There were some serious child abusers working at Epuni when I was there. I will never forget being locked in a room in one of the wings and hearing the boy next door being raped by a staff member, knowing that that was happening and wondering when it would be my turn.

Alan David Moncreif-Wright was one of the staff members. He was a prolific offender, who had been caught abusing children in Hamilton but he was allowed to leave that institution and get a job at Epuni. Moncreif-Wright was a House Master – roughly the equivalent of a guard, a prison officer. He slept on site. The House Masters were all powerful. They had easy access to children. We had to obey them – if we didn’t we were disciplined.

I remember the first time Mr Moncreif-Wright abused me, he found a reason to send me to my room. Once in the room he came in and he sexually abused me. There was no escape. I was trapped.

After nine months at Epuni, I was taken out of there and put into a Family Home in Titahi Bay, Porirua. I was there for about three years. A similar culture existed there, but not as bad. The first day I arrived I distinctly remember sitting in the lounge. Another boy wandered in and, without introducing himself, he just punched me fair in the face. I had just come from a pretty rugged environment and I retaliated, which got me into trouble. Later I said to the boy, “Why did you do that? I don’t know you at all – I have never done anything to you.” He said, “because the kingpin told me to do it”. Some of the kids that were at the Family Home had been in Epuni Boys’ Home, so it was violent.

The male guardian at the Family Home was violent towards the kids. He sexually abused the girls. It was another abusive environment which saw my behaviour and wellbeing deteriorate. I was given an ultimatum when I was expelled from Mana College that I could do three or four months in Epuni Boys’ Home and then be given ‘school dispensation’ to allow me to go to work, or I could go to Invercargill Borstal. Those were my two options. I chose the first one.

The second time I went to Epuni, it was for about three to four months. Moncreif-Wright wasn’t there the second time around and I distinctly remember my first day back asking if he was there. I will never forget the response: “No he’s not, but turn your lights out at night, you’ll have a better chance.” I knew exactly what that meant.

The culture was the same and so were some of the staff. I remember I was standing on the line with the other kids and a fight had broken out. One of the staff was almost salivating over it and he just turned around to me and said, “Oh Keith, these kids aren’t quite as tough as when you were here last time”. These two kids were trying to kill each other and he did nothing to try and stop them.

When I left Epuni the second time around, I found myself throwing parcels in a sack for the Post Office at not quite 15 years old. I was still a ward of the State. I was not in good shape. I hated the world. I had a destructive attitude which saw me get into trouble, linking up with another kid or two from Epuni Boys’ Home and getting a minor criminal record at a young age.

I had no education. I was abusing alcohol, drifting from job to job, from boarding house to boarding house, with no sense of what I should do with my life to try and improve things. Looking back on my time at Epuni, the only positive was leaving it.

Many decades later, I went to police and told them what Moncreif-Wright did to me. The reason I made a criminal complaint against Moncreif-Wright was because somebody else had complained. Police contacted me as a potential witness, and I told them what happened to me. It ended up with three of us being involved in a criminal case against Moncreif-Wright.

I remember the Judge saying to Moncreif-Wright, who was deciding whether to change his plea, “you’ve got exactly five minutes to show these people some compassion.” He went out with his lawyer and came back and pleaded guilty. That told me something about the way the Judge saw the case.

In 2011 Moncreif-Wright was convicted of eight sexual offences in the Wellington District Court, including six against me. It turned out that in 1972 Moncreif-Wright had been convicted of three charges of indecent assault on boys aged under 16, and two charges of attempted assault. In 1988, the High Court sentenced him to four years’ jail for serious sexual offences. I cannot give an exact number of people Moncreif-Wright offended against, but I am very confident that he was a prolific offender. 

It is not possible in my mind that the other staff at Epuni were unaware of abuse by their fellow staff members. I never saw a staff member face any consequences for their actions on either of my two stints at Epuni. I believe they did not face any consequences because of an administration that either didn’t know how to deal with it or didn’t want to. Either way they were as complicit as the offender.

State care had a devastating effect on me in those formative years. The impact of that period has continued throughout my life. I always wanted to get justice and an explanation for what happened to me.

I have thought about what a better system might be. First of all, there needs to be culture change. There are a range of things and the important thing is that when a young person goes into care, they are treated with dignity. Their needs may be different from others – it is about that person’s future. Investing at that level in those formative years is where you avoid having inter-generational prison populations, the continued growth of the gangs and all those negative outcomes.

Until it changes and the investment is made for young people, you are going to get the outcomes that happen here, which we all pay a price for. A massive impact on this country because we get it so wrong in those formative years.

Source

Witness Statement, Keith Wiffin (29 October 2019).

Survivor experiences
  • Survivor experience: Andrew Brown
  • Survivor experience: Ann Thompson
  • Survivor experience Antony Dalton-Wilson
  • Survivor experience: Beverly Wardle-Jackson
  • Survivor experience: Catherine Daniels
  • Survivor experience: Chris Finan
  • Survivor experience: Christina Ramage
  • Survivor experience: David Crichton
  • Survivor experience: Ms FT
  • Survivor experience: Ms HA
  • Survivor experience: Mr KA
  • Survivor experience: David Williams (aka John Williams)
  • Survivor experience: Debbie Morris-Jenkins
  • Survivor experience: Eugene Ryder
  • Survivor experience: Fa'afete Taito
  • Survivor experience: Fa’amoana Luafutu
  • Survivor experience: Faithful Disciple
  • Survivor experience: Frances Tagaloa
  • Survivor experience: Gary Williams
  • Survivor experience: Gwyneth Beard (also know as Piwi)
  • Survivor experience: Mr LF
  • Survivor experience: Ms M
  • Survivor experience: Ms MC
  • Survivor experience: Hēmi Hema
  • Survivor experiences: The Hopa whānau
  • Survivor experience: Ihorangi Reweti-Peters
  • Survivor experience: Irene Priest
  • Survivor experience: Jesse Kett
  • Survivor experience: Jim Goodwin
  • Survivor experience: Joan Bellingham
  • Survivor experience: Joshy Fitzgerald
  • Survivor experience: Kamahl Tupetagi
  • Survivor experience: Ms MK
  • Survivor experience: Ms NH
  • Survivor experience: Ms NI
  • Survivor experience: Karah Mackie
  • Survivor experience: Keith Wiffin
  • Survivor experience: Kylee Maloney
  • Survivor experience: Lily
  • Survivor experience: Lusi Faiva
  • Survivor experience: Maggie Wilkinson
  • Survivor experience: Ms NT
  • Survivor experience: Shannon
  • Survivor experience: Mr OB
  • Survivor experience: Neta Kerepeti
  • Survivor experience: Nooroa Robert
  • Survivor experience: Paul Beale
  • Survivor experience: Paul Zentveld
  • Survivor experience: Peter Evaroa
  • Survivor experience: Philip Laws
  • Survivor experience: Poi McIntyre
  • Survivor experience: Rachael Umaga
  • Survivor experience: Mr NK
  • Survivor experience: Mr NL
  • Survivor experience: Mr NM
  • Survivor experience: Renée Habluetzel
  • Survivor experience: Callum and Victoria Turnbull
  • Survivor experience: Rūpene Amato
  • Survivor experience: Scott Carr
  • Survivor experience: Shaye Parkinson
  • Survivor experience: Sir Robert Martin
  • Survivor experience: Skyler Quinn
  • Survivor experience: Susan Kenny
  • Survivor experience: Tani Tekoronga
  • Survivor experience: Ms OF
  • Survivor experience: Mr PM
  • Survivor experience: Ms QP
  • Survivor experience: Tania Kinita
  • Survivor experience: Taraia Brown
  • Survivor experience: Terry Le Compte
  • Survivor experience: Toni Jarvis
  • Survivor experience: Tupua Urlich
  • Survivor experience: Whiti Ronaki
  • Survivor experience: Wiremu Waikari
  • Survivor experience: Zion Pilgrim
  • Survivor experience: Mr RA
  • Survivor experience: Mr SK
  • Survivor experience: Mr SL
  • Survivor experience Mr UB
  • Survivor experience: Mr VT
  • Survivor experience: Mr VV
Site Logo Light
Connect with us
  • Find us on Facebook


    • Legal Menu
      • Privacy policy
      • Terms
      • Accessibility
      • Contact us
    • Ngā pūrongo Reports
      • Whanaketia
      • Stolen Lives, Marked Souls
      • Beautiful Children
      • He Purapura Ora, he Māra Tipu
      • Tāwharautia: Pūrongo o te Wā
      • Administrative report
    • Ngā purapura ora Survivors
      • Getting help and support
      • Questions and answers
      • Survivor stories
    • Rangahau me ngā tūhonhono Research and engagement
      • How people engaged with the Inquiry
      • Public hearings
      • Research
    • Te tuara me tōna raupapa Background and material
      • About the Royal Commission
      • Inquiry team
      • Advisory Groups and Reference Groups
      • Quarterly reports
      • Timeline
      • Pānui
    • Kohinga tuhinga Document library
      • Document Library
      • Case studies
      • Recommendations
      • Summaries and guides

    © 2025 Abuse in Care - Royal Commission of Inquiry